Who is Matt The Medicare Guy?

Matt Mitchell / CEO

Matt started in the insurance industry in 2008. He became passionate about Medicare when he noticed how confused his grandmother was with trying to figure out all the parts to Medicare and what they all meant. Matt has now made it his mission to take a confusing topic like Medicare and make it simple!

His goal is to help each person he speaks with compare the pro’s and con’s of each option they have in order to make educated decisions based on facts.

By providing the information above, I grant permission for a licensed insurance agent to call or email me regarding my Medicare Insurance Plan options including Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, and Prescription Drug Plans.”

Meet Our Team

Meet the Experts Behind Your Protection.

Paul Vossler

Licensed Agent

Rebecca Hayes

Senior licensed Agent

Zach Jones

Licensed Agent

Eric Raasch

Licensed Agent

Ray Bucklew

Licensed Agent

Aaron Aeschliman

licensed Agent

Kristen Brown

Licensed Agent

Valerie Edmonds

Licensed Agent

Justin Schrack

Licensed Agent/Client Support

Testimonials

Client Stories of Confidence and Care.

I wanted to thank Paul for making my transition to meficare a breeze. So easy

marlena remington Avatar marlena remington

Aaron was very knowledgeable and made my transition to Medicare seedless!

Ken Reisman Avatar Ken Reisman

Agent answered all my questions and was very pleasant. Plus she has stayed in touch to answer any other questions I might have and to make sure I received my documents.

Veronica F Avatar Veronica F

Thank you for all your help with all my questions for 2025. You were so helpful and patient with all my questions. Have an awesome year.

Christine Cordova Avatar Christine Cordova

Beginning with the first video I watched from Midwest Medigap to the numerous follow up informational emails and discussions, I felt like Midwest Medigap was available to answer all of my questions and explain them in a way that I could easily understand. I am happy with the end result and am sending my husband to Midwest Medigap to get setup with the supplemental insurance he will need when he is eligible for Medicare.

Caroline Rawa Avatar Caroline Rawa

Paul was extremely patient and took time to explain everything to me. I am new to Medicare, so I was VERY skeptical of all the telephone calls, emails and letters that I was receiving. As it turned out, I am VERY pleased with his service. So much so, that I have referred friends.

media thumbnail 0
Denise Grandberry Avatar Denise Grandberry

Outta sight, outta mind.. the process for me was totally hands-off, Paul accomplished it all, remotely. And, this year was my second, didn't need to do anything other than approve and sign.

Larry Burleson Avatar Larry Burleson

Aaron was very knowledgeable and helped me to make the best choices of Medicare for me.

Sherry Gammon Avatar Sherry Gammon

After getting stuck behind the eight ball when my old insurance plan closed up, I did it right for this year’s health care selection by contacting Midwest Medigap. It was very organized. I called them and set up a phone call appointment easily. Matthew reviewed all of my options, and we came up with a plan that works best for me. He was also real good at follow-up, contacting me before the cut-off to make sure I had my new insurance card and details.

Bill Gobber Avatar Bill Gobber

Matt was great. He very patiently went thru numerous Medicare providers and compared all financial considerations so I could make informed side-by-side comparisons.

David Brehmer Avatar David Brehmer

Becky has been instrumental in working with me on Medicare/Medigap issues and helping to understand the different insurance plans available in my area. I have the best insurance available for my situation. I have been using my insurance for about two months and I’m very happy with it.

Marianne Mahin Avatar Marianne Mahin

Great experience! Very helpful on all aspects of my journey.

Kelly Klausing Avatar Kelly Klausing